New York Bagel Cafe

Reviews

• Tara S.

  star star star star star 12 June 2026

  This place has the best bagels. We go here all the time and I cannot figure out why anyone would give it less than 4 or 5 stars. Very fast service, outdoor seating, bagels have always been up to par, and staff is great. Definitely try this place out!
  
  FYI they close at 2 every day. This is clearly posted.

• Steve S.

  star star star star star 7 June 2026

  Good reminder the other day, Don't Assume!
  Drove by here every day for a year thinking there can't be good, authentic, Jewish bagels in Lakewood - totally wrong. They're pretty darn good...dense, heavy, and large - and they make decent breakfast sandwiches. So much better than the crappy, air-filled, tasteless bagels in King Suppers and Safeway. Rosenbergs in 5 pts. is still the ultimate bagel, possibly one of the best in the country.
  NYBC staff has always been nice and pleasant. All good. Thank you!

• Simon D.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 29 May 2026

  So we used to eat here before we moved away. We're back and were really stoked to collect a bakers dozen to take home on Thursday. A really pleasant lady cut them all for us and my partner tipped well.
  Friday morning was great, this morning -- not so much. We had a problem (see pic below) and we called asking to speak to a manager, the young lady on the phone stated she was and I relayed our situation. I asked what we could do about it - "we can replace the bagel or give you a refund". No apology. Needless to say we'll be back just one more time-to collect our refund.
  I have very short hair and my partner is bald.

• Anna C.

  star star star star star_border 21 May 2026

  Best bagel I've had in Denver. Such a cute little joint tucked away in a strip mall along South Wadsworth. You automatically smile when you walk into this cafe, everyone from the customers to all the staff are smiling and the energy is so positive...even really early in the morning! The bagel selection is just right, enough to make you think but not so many that you're overwhelmed. The bagels...amazing. Fresh and chewy and so good! The flavors of the bagel and the flavor of the cream cheese don't compete but complement each other.
  
  It seems to be family run from some of the youngest to the older generations. It's so fun to see them all working together and putting smiles on faces and filling bellies. Really happy I stumbled upon this gem!

• Marcy F.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 17 May 2026

  Ants all over. The bagels are okay dense and hard, not worth it for terrible service. Weekend workers are great, during the week the team there is rude, lazy inattentive and most of all unprofessional.